Redthies wrote:Welcome Gene. I’m new here as well, and it’s a great crowd! I’m looking too add a BBS Carbine in .357 soon.
Those of you that are in states where you HAVE to hunt deer with straight wall pistol cartridges, could you explain what the rationale is for it? I have a few ideas on it, but the govt regulators rarely use common sense in my experience.
I’m in an area where deer get very large, but we can use any centerfire cartridge to hunt them. There are a few spots where only shot is allowed (islands, or tight populated valleys).
I can only speak for myself. The longest clear shot I can take on my property, which is mostly dense forest, is a little over 100yds. So a pistol round (at least the 357 and up) have the range and terminal ballistics to git 'er done from a rifle, if I do my part. As for mulies vs. whitetail, if you hit the vitals a .357 or better is perfectly capable of taking either one. All we have here are whitetails, usually around 130lbs or so. In MS, there are no caliber restrictions for deer whatsoever, and I know people who have taken deer with a .22lr all the way up to 12gage slugs. Some of my kin and neighbors hunt with more traditional long guns, and sometimes with a revolver. All depends on how much land you have and how good of a shot you are.
Here's the
estimated preliminary ballistics for the Underwood 210grn XTP .41mag out of a 16.5" barrel that I worked up a few days ago.
