Best .357 ammo for deer?

[russjb60]

Thank you for the help. I will let you know how it goes.

[PT7]

0HRF.jpg (30.75 KiB) Viewed 4781 times

Welcome to the Forum from the Show-Me-State, Russjb60. Deer season is rapidly approaching. Certain to see more and more posts about this hunting season in the days ahead. Stick around and join in often!
PT7

[Redthies]

I have been asking the same question LOL, I have heard 158 gr and 180gr. looking forward to deer hunting this year with my henry great gun. Next thing will be a scope old eyes.

Welcome to the forum. I ended up using 158 grain American Eagle SJSP in my BBSC last fall. They were by far the most accurate in my .357, but I didn’t see any legal deer, so I can’t say how well they will work. Deer season opened on Tuesday this week, so I’m hoping to have some insight soon!

Happy hunting you guys!

[Cofisher]

+1 on the American Eagle 158 soft point. I dropped a decent sized whitetail last season at about 40 yards. A short trail and good bleed out.

I also agree with the accuracy of the round. I have spent the recent months making my own. Using the Nosler Sporting Handgun bullet. 158 grain SJHP. It shoots as accurately as the AE.

Good luck.

[Mags]

.
I've been impressed with Federal American Eagle ammo in all the calibers I use. .45LC, .45ACP and 5.56.

[russjb60]

thank you all for the input I MOUNTED UTG 3x9x32 bug buster on my henry went to the range today . tried Hornady/Federal/ the Fusion and the lever evolution. they all were 158 grain except for the lever evolution was 140 gr had about a 2" to 3 "groups at a 100 yards.so pretty happy with that. probably wont shoot over 50 to 75 yds. see no need ,I hunt in some big woods. most shots are under a 100 yards

[Redthies]

I have a 1-4 Bugbuster I bought for my Ruger .44 Carbine, and have contemplated mounting it on either my .357 or my
.45-70. So far, I haven’t found a reason yet as I upgraded both to peeps, and seem to be able to hit “the zone” at 50-60 yards.

I hunt in this sort of terrain a lot, so a scope is an unnecessary impediment: