Site seems to be OK. Load issue should be resolved now.
Better brass?
Better brass?
Is there such thing as better pistol brass for 45 lc? Not having issues, just curious. I am mostly using star line .
I love all God's creatures, some are better with gravy.
-
Rugerfanboy
Re: Better brass?
Starline is my first choice in pistol brass. I have about 5000 pieces of there brass. Quality and uniformity is second to none. Eventually, Starline brass is all I will have for pistol cartridge cases. The only thing better than Starline brass is FREE Starline Brass.Oksrt wrote:Is there such thing as better pistol brass for 45 lc? Not having issues, just curious. I am mostly using star line .
- JEBar
- Town Marshal / Deputy Admin
- Posts: 20441
- Joined: Sun Mar 20, 2016 10:58 pm
- Location: central NC

Re: Better brass?
echo the positive experience using Starline .... while I keep brass from factory ammo and reload it, Starline is the only brass I buy in bulk
-
tx gunrunner
Re: Better brass?
In the 1000's of Starline brass I've loaded I only found 4 that was bad . I resize new brass before loading them and I found 4 split after coming out of the resizing die . I had 3 more split after firing and they all were 357 mag brass loaded to 38 spec. No more split in the next reloading of them . The primer pocket are very uniform which is a big plus in my book .
- clovishound
- Drover
- Posts: 2527
- Joined: Wed Apr 13, 2016 4:18 pm
- Location: Summerville SC

Re: Better brass?
The best brass is the stuff you pick up at the range for free.
Not much .45 lc on the floor. I did have a hard time walking away from some 45-70 a guy was tossing in the bucket. I don't have a 45-70. I don't plan on ever having a 45-70. It was some big beautiful brass.
When I find some .357 magnum on the floor it's like Christmas.
Not much .45 lc on the floor. I did have a hard time walking away from some 45-70 a guy was tossing in the bucket. I don't have a 45-70. I don't plan on ever having a 45-70. It was some big beautiful brass.
When I find some .357 magnum on the floor it's like Christmas.
There is, I think, humor here which does not translate well from English to sanity. - Sanya
Re: Better brass?
OP, most brass you will find is fine, just as long as it hasn't been reloaded 27 times. 
If you're gonna buy it, you can't go wrong with Starline. Also, if you don't have access to any free range brass, Sometimesmit makes sense to just look for sales on factory ammo, and shoot the stuff for the brass.
If you're gonna buy it, you can't go wrong with Starline. Also, if you don't have access to any free range brass, Sometimesmit makes sense to just look for sales on factory ammo, and shoot the stuff for the brass.
Re: Better brass?
Thanks for confirming my thoughts. 
I love all God's creatures, some are better with gravy.
Re: Better brass?
Starline is good brass and if I am buying new brass that would be my preference. I bought one box of PMC .44 Magnum ammunition a couple of years ago when .44 Magnum brass was out of stock everywhere. My big gripe with their brass was the primer pocket holes were not centered - not even close. Don't know if that will affect bullet performance but I thought it was pretty shoddy.
H001, H001L, H004, H001TM, H001TLB, H006, H010, H012M, H012GR
NRA Member, GOA Member, ISRA Member, ILCCW
NRA Member, GOA Member, ISRA Member, ILCCW
-
Bugs
Re: Better brass?
I like Federal Brass for 45 acp. The local sheriff's dept shot regularly at our private range. Picked up thousands of once fired Federal 45's & Lake City .223 over the years. Then they had to switch to Speer. Federal Brass is thicker in the neck area than Speer, you can feel it when you resize it or just Mic it. Speer still works but is not as good. Winchester is my 2nd go to for 45's. Starline makes great stuff but i prefer my brass to be FREE.
-
tx gunrunner
Re: Better brass?
When I got 44-40 Vaquero pistols and 44-40 Rossi rifle in about 1995 I got 400 rounds of Rem factory ammo . Took 300 rds and shot it SASS/ CAS matches and reloaded it for over 18 yrs . The brass NEVER failed in over 20 yrs and reloaded over 80 times I used it . Only the pockets for the primers were getting loose and wearing out . When I sold the gun I still never lost or spilt any brass and gave the old brass loaded to the new gun owners . I loaded the 500 rds of NEW RP brass I purchase over 10 yrs ago for my Sheriff Vaquero I built .


-
Mad Charlie
Re: Better brass?
Good morning gentlemen, 1st post here so a little about me:
I am a retired machinist and mechanic and I have been shooting and handloading for over 40 years.
I am really picky about some things and loading perfect ammunition is one of them. I have learned
quite a bit about loading over the years, but I will probably never know it all.
As far as cases go, I too am a great believer in Starline, they do make fine cases.
A while back I bought some Jagemann cases, and guys, they are every bit as good as Starline and
maybe a bit better. The quality is visibly perfect and their performance has been outstanding.
Starline and Jagemann, those are the only ones I buy.
No, I am not involved with them, except as a very satisfied customer.
I am a retired machinist and mechanic and I have been shooting and handloading for over 40 years.
I am really picky about some things and loading perfect ammunition is one of them. I have learned
quite a bit about loading over the years, but I will probably never know it all.
As far as cases go, I too am a great believer in Starline, they do make fine cases.
A while back I bought some Jagemann cases, and guys, they are every bit as good as Starline and
maybe a bit better. The quality is visibly perfect and their performance has been outstanding.
Starline and Jagemann, those are the only ones I buy.
No, I am not involved with them, except as a very satisfied customer.
- CT_Shooter
- Administrator emeritus
- Posts: 5778
- Joined: Mon Mar 21, 2016 8:42 am
- Location: Connecticut

Re: Better brass?
Welcome to the forum from CT, MC. I'm glad you joined in the conversation.
H006M BBB .357 - H001 Classic .22LR - Uberti/Taylors & Co. SmokeWagon .357 5.5" - Uberti/Taylors & Co. RanchHand .22LR 5.5" - Colt King Cobra Carry 2" - Colt Official Police 38spl 4"
-
Rugerfanboy
Re: Better brass?
Welcome aboard Mad Charlie and thanks for your review of the Jagemann Brass.Mad Charlie wrote:Good morning gentlemen, 1st post here so a little about me:
I am a retired machinist and mechanic and I have been shooting and handloading for over 40 years.
I am really picky about some things and loading perfect ammunition is one of them. I have learned
quite a bit about loading over the years, but I will probably never know it all.
As far as cases go, I too am a great believer in Starline, they do make fine cases.
A while back I bought some Jagemann cases, and guys, they are every bit as good as Starline and
maybe a bit better. The quality is visibly perfect and their performance has been outstanding.
Starline and Jagemann, those are the only ones I buy.
No, I am not involved with them, except as a very satisfied customer.
-
tx gunrunner
-
Bugs
Re: Better brass?
Learn something new every day. I had not heard of Jagemann but will check them out.Mad Charlie wrote:Good morning gentlemen, 1st post here so a little about me:
I am a retired machinist and mechanic and I have been shooting and handloading for over 40 years.
I am really picky about some things and loading perfect ammunition is one of them. I have learned
quite a bit about loading over the years, but I will probably never know it all.
As far as cases go, I too am a great believer in Starline, they do make fine cases.
A while back I bought some Jagemann cases, and guys, they are every bit as good as Starline and
maybe a bit better. The quality is visibly perfect and their performance has been outstanding.
Starline and Jagemann, those are the only ones I buy.
No, I am not involved with them, except as a very satisfied customer.
- CT_Shooter
- Administrator emeritus
- Posts: 5778
- Joined: Mon Mar 21, 2016 8:42 am
- Location: Connecticut

Re: Better brass?
The Jagemann brand is available at Midway USA. Their .357 cases are $17.49 per 100.
https://www.midwayusa.com/jagemann/b?bid=3061
https://www.midwayusa.com/jagemann/b?bid=3061
H006M BBB .357 - H001 Classic .22LR - Uberti/Taylors & Co. SmokeWagon .357 5.5" - Uberti/Taylors & Co. RanchHand .22LR 5.5" - Colt King Cobra Carry 2" - Colt Official Police 38spl 4"

