Site seems to be OK. Load issue should be resolved now.
Henry New Original 44-40 vs 45LC
- Vaquero
- Ranch Boss
- Posts: 12175
- Joined: Mon Mar 21, 2016 12:56 am
- Location: Somewhere between Memphis & Nashville

Re: Henry New Original 44-40 vs 45LC
Good luck in your search Ed.
Searching is half the fun, enjoy.
RP
Searching is half the fun, enjoy.
RP
Monte Walsh "You have No idea how little I care".
Ain't No Apologies for My Temperament
Si vis pacem, para bellum
H001, H006, H012
Ain't No Apologies for My Temperament
Si vis pacem, para bellum
H001, H006, H012
-
Mistered
Re: Henry New Original 44-40 vs 45LC
Oh, it's more like if I happen to see one in a LGS, pawn shop or at a show.
Not really 'actively' looking.
Oddly most of my guns have come to me this way - interested in something but not looking - and then one shows up - but I have passed on many I was interested in (like the Navy) and typically what I am interested others are as well so it' s usually slim pickins' for me.
Another example is I am looking for a Mod 60-4 in 3" with adjustable sights. Again I passed on a very nice one several years ago in a pawn shop and a kinda sorta nice one fairly recently - but it had issues. It had come from Alaska and the non- stainless parts (trigger & hammer & sights) had some surface rust that had been cleaned off but they were stained.
Even the rest of the gun, while stainless had a dull finish and would have needed a polish job to bring back to normal.
Not really 'actively' looking.
Oddly most of my guns have come to me this way - interested in something but not looking - and then one shows up - but I have passed on many I was interested in (like the Navy) and typically what I am interested others are as well so it' s usually slim pickins' for me.
Another example is I am looking for a Mod 60-4 in 3" with adjustable sights. Again I passed on a very nice one several years ago in a pawn shop and a kinda sorta nice one fairly recently - but it had issues. It had come from Alaska and the non- stainless parts (trigger & hammer & sights) had some surface rust that had been cleaned off but they were stained.
Even the rest of the gun, while stainless had a dull finish and would have needed a polish job to bring back to normal.
Re: Henry New Original 44-40 vs 45LC
I decided on the 45LC but my problem now is finding one in stock somewhere. Any suggestions!
“Nobody gets to be a cowboy forever”
Monty Walsh
H001T
H006
H011C
H010B
Ruger Blackhawk 44 mag 7.5”
Ruger Blackhawk 45 long colt 5.5”
Taurus Raging Hunter 454 Casull 6.75”
Ravin R26 Crossbow
Monty Walsh
H001T
H006
H011C
H010B
Ruger Blackhawk 44 mag 7.5”
Ruger Blackhawk 45 long colt 5.5”
Taurus Raging Hunter 454 Casull 6.75”
Ravin R26 Crossbow
-
Mistered
Re: Henry New Original 44-40 vs 45LC
Heck go to the source and contact Henry!but my problem now is finding one in stock somewhere.
Maybe they will hear your 'desire' to have one and facilitate a transfer of one to your LGS.
Just 'grabbing at straws' but ya never know until you ask!
- RanchRoper
- Forum Ambassador
- Posts: 12964
- Joined: Mon Mar 21, 2016 12:14 am
- Location: Land of Shining Mountains, Alberta

Re: Henry New Original 44-40 vs 45LC
Yup, HRA will help you locate one.
Kibler Colonial Flintlock .50
Ohkínohkomit - Shoot skillfully
-
Mistered
Re: Henry New Original 44-40 vs 45LC
Thank you .that is an excellent recommendation
One of my 'Additional Duty Assignments' for the company I work for is that of Last Ditch Negotiator for a variety of issues.
Occasionally company Ownership/Management will come to me as an 'unbiased' voice to deal with a problem and will outline me with the details and ask I do my best to resolve the problem even though it is not necessarily in my department.
One of my premier attributes is that of verbal communication and I use it to the best of my abilities.
Sometimes I can resolve the problem, sometimes it requires a 'trade off' and sometimes it costs us money.
If it were me I'd have that Henry on the way on the next business day!
- RanchRoper
- Forum Ambassador
- Posts: 12964
- Joined: Mon Mar 21, 2016 12:14 am
- Location: Land of Shining Mountains, Alberta

Re: Henry New Original 44-40 vs 45LC
You'll enjoy that rifle in 45 Colt. Best of luck.
Kibler Colonial Flintlock .50
Ohkínohkomit - Shoot skillfully
Re: Henry New Original 44-40 vs 45LC
Another point in favor of the .45 Colt is that the necks on the 44-40 cases are soft and must be kept trimmed to the right length or during reloading a lot of cases will be ruined.
Re: Henry New Original 44-40 vs 45LC
I was able to find a 45LC at a Sportsman’s Warehouse in the DC area. Should be here by 4/27. We’ll see.
“Nobody gets to be a cowboy forever”
Monty Walsh
H001T
H006
H011C
H010B
Ruger Blackhawk 44 mag 7.5”
Ruger Blackhawk 45 long colt 5.5”
Taurus Raging Hunter 454 Casull 6.75”
Ravin R26 Crossbow
Monty Walsh
H001T
H006
H011C
H010B
Ruger Blackhawk 44 mag 7.5”
Ruger Blackhawk 45 long colt 5.5”
Taurus Raging Hunter 454 Casull 6.75”
Ravin R26 Crossbow
- Vaquero
- Ranch Boss
- Posts: 12175
- Joined: Mon Mar 21, 2016 12:56 am
- Location: Somewhere between Memphis & Nashville

Re: Henry New Original 44-40 vs 45LC
Good deal,
RP
RP
Monte Walsh "You have No idea how little I care".
Ain't No Apologies for My Temperament
Si vis pacem, para bellum
H001, H006, H012
Ain't No Apologies for My Temperament
Si vis pacem, para bellum
H001, H006, H012
- Rifletom
- Deputy Marshal
- Posts: 4015
- Joined: Tue Aug 21, 2018 11:26 pm
- Location: California Territory

Re: Henry New Original 44-40 vs 45LC
Deacon, if the D.C. Deal doesn't pan out, Kentucky Guns or budsgunshop.com, both in Kentucky, should work. Good luck.
Re: Henry New Original 44-40 vs 45LC
I’ve bought 90% of my guns from KY Gun Co but right now they do not have it in stock per their website and they are not responding to inquiries. I prefer KYGunCo as they are only 30 miles from me and great to deal with. I ordered it from Bud’s online and the order sat there for a week in “in processing” mode and now their site says out of stock. I will contact Henry if Sportsman’s Warehouse doesn’t produce.
“Nobody gets to be a cowboy forever”
Monty Walsh
H001T
H006
H011C
H010B
Ruger Blackhawk 44 mag 7.5”
Ruger Blackhawk 45 long colt 5.5”
Taurus Raging Hunter 454 Casull 6.75”
Ravin R26 Crossbow
Monty Walsh
H001T
H006
H011C
H010B
Ruger Blackhawk 44 mag 7.5”
Ruger Blackhawk 45 long colt 5.5”
Taurus Raging Hunter 454 Casull 6.75”
Ravin R26 Crossbow
Re: Henry New Original 44-40 vs 45LC
Henry New Original 45LC arrived today. Sportsman’s Warehouse came through as advertised. Ironically I received emails from both Bud’s Gun Shop and KY Gun Co saying they had the rifle available now. Now if this rain would just stop so I could get to the range. Thanks for all the help in picking a caliber.
“Nobody gets to be a cowboy forever”
Monty Walsh
H001T
H006
H011C
H010B
Ruger Blackhawk 44 mag 7.5”
Ruger Blackhawk 45 long colt 5.5”
Taurus Raging Hunter 454 Casull 6.75”
Ravin R26 Crossbow
Monty Walsh
H001T
H006
H011C
H010B
Ruger Blackhawk 44 mag 7.5”
Ruger Blackhawk 45 long colt 5.5”
Taurus Raging Hunter 454 Casull 6.75”
Ravin R26 Crossbow
- JEBar
- Town Marshal / Deputy Admin
- Posts: 20447
- Joined: Sun Mar 20, 2016 10:58 pm
- Location: central NC

Re: Henry New Original 44-40 vs 45LC
congrats on your new Henry .... the 45LC is building a pretty good size following .... looking forward to pictures, comments and range reports as you become better acquainted with yours .... be sure to follow the link below and add it to our community total
http://henryrifleforums.com/viewtopic.p ... 68#p133668
http://henryrifleforums.com/viewtopic.p ... 68#p133668
-
Chucksolo1
- Wrangler
- Posts: 82
- Joined: Sat Aug 17, 2019 4:04 pm

Re: Henry New Original 44-40 vs 45LC
Very jealous now as this is my "dream" gun!! Mine would be in .45 Colt, that is, if I could afford one!
- Rifletom
- Deputy Marshal
- Posts: 4015
- Joined: Tue Aug 21, 2018 11:26 pm
- Location: California Territory

Re: Henry New Original 44-40 vs 45LC
I'd say you done good Deacon. You and everyone will enjoy the rifle and caliber. Enjoy! And pics when you can.
- RanchRoper
- Forum Ambassador
- Posts: 12964
- Joined: Mon Mar 21, 2016 12:14 am
- Location: Land of Shining Mountains, Alberta

Re: Henry New Original 44-40 vs 45LC
Enjoy your new rifle!
Kibler Colonial Flintlock .50
Ohkínohkomit - Shoot skillfully
Re: Henry New Original 44-40 vs 45LC
Congrats on the new rifle. I have that in 45lc also and it shot great right out of the box. I never had to touch the sights.
Jim
Jim
Henry BBB 44mag
Henry 1860
Henry 45/70 Brass
Henry 1860
Henry 45/70 Brass
Re: Henry New Original 44-40 vs 45LC
Deacon, we're practically neighbors. I live in the Bardstown/Etown area.
. I have a Big Boy in 45 Colt, two of them, actually. One is a CCH receiver, and the other is the plain blue receiver. The 45 Colt is a fun caliber to load and shoot; I used my CCH to take a buck and a doe last fall.
The only thing I would say is, I'd feel shortchanged if I was your granddaughter. Henry vs Glock is not a fair trade.
The only thing I would say is, I'd feel shortchanged if I was your granddaughter. Henry vs Glock is not a fair trade.