New 170gr Federal vs hand loads

[Vaquero]

Picked up a box of Federal 170gr 30-30 ammo this afternoon and wanted to compare to my favorite 170gr load.
Sierra Pro hunters, and 29.2 grs. of IMR 3031.
Off the picnic table in the side yard, 55 yds. to the backstop.

20220504_180200.jpg (85 KiB) Viewed 1281 times

The federal had a spread of 5/8" center to center, and mine load was 3/4".

RP

[BigAl52]

Pretty good shootin Id say. Either load would work for me.

[Vaquero]

Pretty good shootin Id say. Either load would work for me.

Right but the factory stuff figures out to $1.32 ea, where as having had the brass and then loading it comes to .54, .55 cents.
But the next lb. of powder may be more expensive. I do have one in reserve.
I just scoped another this evening, my first Marlin. I put a 2x7 Vortex on it, now to see what it likes.

RP

[BigAl52]

Your time loading that stuff is worth something. I realize its a hobby and fun but its still time. Powder Im seeing is about 40 a lb.

[Rifletom]

That Federal shot pretty tight. But, at the price difference, I'd certainly stay with the handloads also. For those that don't handload, the Fed looks good. Darn good shooting either way Randy.

[GFK]

To me, the hand load is more on point! It seems to be closer to center, which should make a difference as it opens in distance.

[DsGrouse]

Your time loading that stuff is worth something. I realize its a hobby and fun but its still time. Powder Im seeing is about 40 a lb.

which is exactly why for the last 30 years i did not reload. Cost wise, it never made sense. Even now, it is arguably a dead even cost factor. I have more time to shoot now, but not the ammo reserves i had 5 years ago. So, that time is taken up by reloading the ammo. it isn't the 1:1 like some people portray it as.

[Vaquero]

Your time loading that stuff is worth something. I realize its a hobby and fun but its still time. Powder Im seeing is about 40 a lb.

Al, those 3 only took a few mins. to load, took me longer to find the dies in that dark cabinet than it almost did to load the 3 rounds.
I use a Lee turret press, so all my dies are all setup, I just pop out one set and pop another in and change shell holders.
Yes it's a hobby and I do enjoy it,
I've said before, I'm not sure if I load to shoot, or
Shoot to reload?

RP

[Slugnut]

Vaquero, was is the velocity of your loadings vs factory ? Also, have you ever tried the Speer 170gr. Hot Core bullets ? My Marlin 336 (30/30) doesn't like them, but my Henry loves them. Maybe it's MG rifling and the Henry is Ballard.

[Shakey Jake]

Pretty close with either one there. Handloading is cheaper for sure.
Jake

[Vaquero]

Vaquero, was is the velocity of your loadings vs factory ? Also, have you ever tried the Speer 170gr. Hot Core bullets ? My Marlin 336 (30/30) doesn't like them, but my Henry loves them. Maybe it's MG rifling and the Henry is Ballard.

I don't own a chrony, so I haven't a clue on that. I just work up to get accuracy and never worried about the speed.
Yes the hot cores shoot just as well as the Speer. Here's a target from back in the fall before deer season.

[Vaquero]

Slugnut, I also shoot both bullets in my Marlin 308mx with very similar results.
Have taken deer with both and can't really tell any difference in performance.
I'd like to try that load of mine in a Henry, as I have 2 Marlins, and they both shoot it well.
I need to try it in the 2 Winchesters but I haven't done it for some odd reason.

RP

[Rifletom]

Slugnut, I've chronographed my standard handload for 30-30 using Hornady 170gr FP and 33.0gr Win 748 powder. LR mag primer, CCI.
MV: 2065-2100 fps. Pretty accurate. Never have chrony'd factory stuff. Probably about the same. Rifle is a 1985 Winchester "Ranger",
which is a Mod 94 with cheaper wood. 20" barrel. That one is also staying put.
Edit: Have a Weaver K4 on it.

[Vaquero]

Tom, I have one of those also, first or second year of the AE, mostly shoot cast with. No scopes on the Winnies though.

20211011_162803.jpg (152.76 KiB) Viewed 1139 times

The cardboard target was down in Fla at a friend's place in 2018, the other was back in the Fall.

RP

[Rifletom]

Tom, I have one of those also, first or second year of the AE, mostly shoot cast with. No scopes on the Winnies though.

20211011_162803.jpg

The cardboard target was down in Fla at a friend's place in 2018, the other was back in the Fall.

RP

Randy, Ohh, I like my Ranger. Looks like we about the same type of furniture on ours. Darn good shooters! Aha! I see that flask there. Heh-heh!
I have some Missouri 165gr rnfp coated with 9.0gr Unique I'm still working with. Should be fun. To the 30-30's and whatever may be in that flask!

[Vaquero]

Tom, I have one of those also, first or second year of the AE, mostly shoot cast with. No scopes on the Winnies though.

20211011_162803.jpg

The cardboard target was down in Fla at a friend's place in 2018, the other was back in the Fall.

RP

Randy, Ohh, I like my Ranger. Looks like we about the same type of furniture on ours. Darn good shooters! Aha! I see that flask there. Heh-heh!
I have some Missouri 165gr rnfp coated with 9.0gr Unique I'm still working with. Should be fun. To the 30-30's and whatever may be in that flask!

it's Buffalo Trace, cheers.
About time for a cold cerveza here.

RP

[Vaquero]

Tom said he had a Ranger, he sent proof.
Mighty fine lookin Winchester RT.

IMG_1792.jpg (172.85 KiB) Viewed 1109 times

FullSizeR(1).jpg (144.95 KiB) Viewed 1109 times

IMG_1789.jpg (167.95 KiB) Viewed 1109 times

RP

[Rifletom]

Thanks Randy for putting those up. Looks better here than on my phone. It's an '85 year, so guessing its an early AE like yours. It's a fine shooter.
Thanks again Randy for the tech help.

[Vaquero]

No problem Tom, anytime.
Don't mind helping when I can.
Pics. aren't any trouble, and I am glad to lend a hand.

RP