"Thoughts on Expertise"
Posted: Fri Aug 16, 2019 10:17 pm
I've always liked the instructions Daytime Dave has for "The Lounge Area." --> Relax with friends on the front or back porch. After doing just that in person during our KC Get-Together and having a great time, I'm doing it again on our forum. 
For almost a month now I've been involved in a new-to-me part of the shooting sports, black powder. I joined a forum where this is the major focus, like we have here on Henry lever-action rifles. This forum is called Muzzleloading Forum (MLF).
Around my time spent this week with the "KC Gang" at our get-together, I've been following a thread on MLF. It was launched by a long-time forum member, who wrote his observations of "The greatest Expert" in muzzleloading. The title of the thread is "Thoughts on Expertise." This caught my attention because it didn't sound like the regular thread discussions about muzzleloading. I was right; it is a reflective, thought piece of years spent in muzzleloading.
As a newbie to muzzleloading, I have asked many basic questions. I was getting a multitude of members sharing what is the way to go with whatever. The responses were so varied, I actually didn't know what to think. This member's comments helped me focus on what I needed to learn, especially being a newbie. Here is what he wrote. Thought some Henry Folk might find this interesting, as well. I'm always learning something new.
(NOTE: I sent a PM to this MLF member and asked his permission to post his thoughts "in their entirety." He said it was okay to do that. And I titled my Henry subject line just as was titled on the MLF thread).
PT7
For almost a month now I've been involved in a new-to-me part of the shooting sports, black powder. I joined a forum where this is the major focus, like we have here on Henry lever-action rifles. This forum is called Muzzleloading Forum (MLF).
Around my time spent this week with the "KC Gang" at our get-together, I've been following a thread on MLF. It was launched by a long-time forum member, who wrote his observations of "The greatest Expert" in muzzleloading. The title of the thread is "Thoughts on Expertise." This caught my attention because it didn't sound like the regular thread discussions about muzzleloading. I was right; it is a reflective, thought piece of years spent in muzzleloading.
As a newbie to muzzleloading, I have asked many basic questions. I was getting a multitude of members sharing what is the way to go with whatever. The responses were so varied, I actually didn't know what to think. This member's comments helped me focus on what I needed to learn, especially being a newbie. Here is what he wrote. Thought some Henry Folk might find this interesting, as well. I'm always learning something new.
(NOTE: I sent a PM to this MLF member and asked his permission to post his thoughts "in their entirety." He said it was okay to do that. And I titled my Henry subject line just as was titled on the MLF thread).
PT7
In my experience wisdom isn't a blanket coverage and it always comes in "degrees" or "levels". A shooter/builder/historian will ultimately know a lot about a spot here, a spot there and nothing really about this area over here. It takes long (more or less) experience for someone/anyone to earn a good grasp of "what makes a good flint", the best powder for a job, where to shoot deer, not to mention ball size, patch material, lube, you name it. Most of what is offered as advice is merely "opinion" and is normally no better or worse than than advice from someone with less experience. Really, now, experts - as commonly understood - DO NOT EXIST when it comes to the ins and outs of muzzleloading. There are pretty good authorities on styles, history, etc. But they know very little more, if that, about the other aspects than the guy who's been into the sport only 5 or 10 years. Think PhD - Pile it Higher and Deeper. Or think of it as learning more and more about less and less. I have my area of expertise, but I'm no expert. Despite the degrees, academic and otherwise, it would be foolish for me to claim to be an expert on anything. There have been a few (very) "renaissance men", but none, I'm sure, writing about muzzleloaders.
Okay, so we have no experts; only certain individuals who know a lot about certain little things. What about celebrated gun builders and the art they produce? Well, they ARE incredibly knowledgeable about anything to do with gun building; but they seldom agree with one another, hhhmmm... Other than that, well, they are about like the rest of us. Certain laws of physics/chemistry are, as far as we know, immutable. These can be a basis for a "pretty sure this is right". Different strokes for different folks and if it works for you it's some degree of right, guaranteed.
