Spring has sprung. Get out and shoot your Henry
My "just right" S&W Model 17 22 LR revolver
- North Country Gal
- Firearms Advisor
- Posts: 6092
- Joined: Thu Apr 07, 2016 12:46 pm
- Location: northern Wisconsin
My "just right" S&W Model 17 22 LR revolver
For those not familiar with S&W revolvers, the Model 17 has been Smith's premium 22 revolver since the 1930s, but until the late 1950s when Smith changed to model numbers on their guns, it was known as the K-22. These are much sought after guns by Smith fans and for good reason. Really doesn't get much better in a 22 LR DA revolver.
I've owned 4 Model 17s of various vintages and barrel lengths over the years. All were great shooters, but the perfect one has eluded my grasp. Two of the older 17s had sticky ejection to the point I needed to tap the ejector rod with a piece of wood to dump empties. This is not uncommon on old 17s, given that Smith cut the chambers very tight on these target 22s. A later 17-6 had just an average trigger for a 17, but an average trigger on a Model 17 is still way ahead of the pack for a trigger on a 22 revolver. The one I should have kept was a 6" barrel 17-3, but being a target shooter, I've always lusted for the rarer 8 3/8" barrel version.
And then I found this one.
It is the perfect Model 17. From a collector's point of view, it ticks all the desirable boxes. For one, it is a 1980 vintage 17-4, so it still has a pinned barrel (and no lock, of course). For another, it has the very desirable 8 3/8th " barrel, which does add to the collectibility, but, more importantly for target work, gets you that long sight radius. For still another, it is a factory 3T model, meaning it came from the factory with a wider target trigger, wider target hammer and the larger target grips and I have the original box to prove it came from the factory that way.
Functionally, it has an outstanding trigger, as good as it gets in a target revolver. Best of all, it shucks empties slick as can be, so no extraction issues. And, of course, it's wonderfully accurate.
First time out with my perfect 17.
A target revolver that can't shoot at 50 yards is not a target revolver. The perfect 17 keeps all 12 in the 6" black on this one. (We reuse our targets, hence the 44 mag hole at the bottom.)
Way too good a shooter to let this one collect dust. That's part of what makes it the just right 17.
I've owned 4 Model 17s of various vintages and barrel lengths over the years. All were great shooters, but the perfect one has eluded my grasp. Two of the older 17s had sticky ejection to the point I needed to tap the ejector rod with a piece of wood to dump empties. This is not uncommon on old 17s, given that Smith cut the chambers very tight on these target 22s. A later 17-6 had just an average trigger for a 17, but an average trigger on a Model 17 is still way ahead of the pack for a trigger on a 22 revolver. The one I should have kept was a 6" barrel 17-3, but being a target shooter, I've always lusted for the rarer 8 3/8" barrel version.
And then I found this one.
It is the perfect Model 17. From a collector's point of view, it ticks all the desirable boxes. For one, it is a 1980 vintage 17-4, so it still has a pinned barrel (and no lock, of course). For another, it has the very desirable 8 3/8th " barrel, which does add to the collectibility, but, more importantly for target work, gets you that long sight radius. For still another, it is a factory 3T model, meaning it came from the factory with a wider target trigger, wider target hammer and the larger target grips and I have the original box to prove it came from the factory that way.
Functionally, it has an outstanding trigger, as good as it gets in a target revolver. Best of all, it shucks empties slick as can be, so no extraction issues. And, of course, it's wonderfully accurate.
First time out with my perfect 17.
A target revolver that can't shoot at 50 yards is not a target revolver. The perfect 17 keeps all 12 in the 6" black on this one. (We reuse our targets, hence the 44 mag hole at the bottom.)
Way too good a shooter to let this one collect dust. That's part of what makes it the just right 17.
6 x
-
- Cowboy
- Posts: 1653
- Joined: Sun Mar 20, 2016 10:25 pm
Re: My "just right" S&W Model 17 22 LR revolver
Very much a premium grade revolver. I have owned several of the 6" barrel models and also the 617. They are very good shooters.
0 x
Re: My "just right" S&W Model 17 22 LR revolver
.
Mine is a 1947 K22 6 inch barrel. Best .22LR revolver I've ever owned.
Mine is a 1947 K22 6 inch barrel. Best .22LR revolver I've ever owned.
2 x
UPDATES: OR passes 114, "one of strictest gun control measures in U.S." https://henryrifleforums.com/viewtopic. ... 34#p213234
Re: My "just right" S&W Model 17 22 LR revolver
NCG, just another very enjoyable thread. Nice looking revolver and thanks again for the history lesson. At least for me anyway and I am sure many others your threads are so enjoyable as I lack the experience that you are so willing and gracious to share. Even though I knew a bit of this about the S&W 17 or K22 I still learned a few things.
There have been more than a few times I considered getting a S&W 17 but have not to this point.
Thank you,
Dan
There have been more than a few times I considered getting a S&W 17 but have not to this point.
Thank you,
Dan
0 x
Re: My "just right" S&W Model 17 22 LR revolver
I have an early 1930's K-22 Outdoorsman it has the gold bead front site so it is one of the first batch made. The other is a 17-3 8 3/8".
0 x
- North Country Gal
- Firearms Advisor
- Posts: 6092
- Joined: Thu Apr 07, 2016 12:46 pm
- Location: northern Wisconsin
Re: My "just right" S&W Model 17 22 LR revolver
Thanks, guys, for the nice comments and also a big thanks for those of you who shared on your K22/17s.
My husband and I also have current production 617s (the stainless, full lug versions of the 17) and those are our basic, workhorse DA 22 revolvers, dreaded lock and all. Bill, especially, considering how many thousands of rounds he's run through his 617, has more than gotten his money's worth out of his 617. Yes, I can shoot slightly tighter groups with a Model 41, a Victory or other semi-auto 22 LR, but still prefer working the revolver. Same with my husband. We are revolver people. That will never change.
As for the 17, yes, it is nice to find that vintage collectible K22/17, but our new production Smiths shoot every bit as well. The difference is the old versus new production techniques, with the old ones getting a lot of hand fitting and polishing and new ones CNC cut with less hand fitting actually needed. It's that old school approach that makes those old Smiths so desirable to S&W purists and collectors. They really don't make them like that 17-4, anymore.
My husband and I also have current production 617s (the stainless, full lug versions of the 17) and those are our basic, workhorse DA 22 revolvers, dreaded lock and all. Bill, especially, considering how many thousands of rounds he's run through his 617, has more than gotten his money's worth out of his 617. Yes, I can shoot slightly tighter groups with a Model 41, a Victory or other semi-auto 22 LR, but still prefer working the revolver. Same with my husband. We are revolver people. That will never change.
As for the 17, yes, it is nice to find that vintage collectible K22/17, but our new production Smiths shoot every bit as well. The difference is the old versus new production techniques, with the old ones getting a lot of hand fitting and polishing and new ones CNC cut with less hand fitting actually needed. It's that old school approach that makes those old Smiths so desirable to S&W purists and collectors. They really don't make them like that 17-4, anymore.
1 x
- markiver54
- Deputy Marshal
- Posts: 10306
- Joined: Sun Nov 04, 2018 11:49 am
- Location: Biue Ridge Mountains, NC
Re: My "just right" S&W Model 17 22 LR revolver
That 17-4 really has me licking my chops! ☺thanks NCG.
I too love revolvers!
I too love revolvers!
0 x
I'm your Huckleberry
Re: My "just right" S&W Model 17 22 LR revolver
Another one I had and sold. Six inch model should have kept it. There pricey now to replace.
0 x
Don't worry about getting older and still doing stupid stuff. You'll do the stupid stuff as always, only much slower. Hold my beer and watch this.......
H001T .22LR
H001T .22LR MONUMENT VALLEY
H003T PUMP .22LR
BBS .41 MAG
SS .357
SIDE GATE 38-55
H001T .22LR
H001T .22LR MONUMENT VALLEY
H003T PUMP .22LR
BBS .41 MAG
SS .357
SIDE GATE 38-55