Hellcat vs. J-frame for CCW

[Hrfunk]

Here's a comparison between he tried and true and the new kid on the block. Let me know your thoughts!

Howard

https://youtu.be/Aa0Oq_9eOd4

[GunnyGene]

Too much concern with size and weight. Capacity wins in this comparison.

[JEBar]

just curious .... given equal circumstances, which one are you the most accurate with (specially on the first shot) ..

[Hrfunk]

just curious .... given equal circumstances, which one are you the most accurate with (specially on the first shot) ..

As much as I hate to admit it, I think that would be the Hellcat. The trigger and sights on that little pistol make a big difference. The D/A pull on the 342 is smooth, but long and somewhat heavy, and the sights are not nearly as visible.

Howard

[markiver54]

I have been very interested in the Hellcat ever since I first became aware of it.
Not much thicker than my XDS, and a significant increase in capacity. If I could step back to pre-purchase of my XDS and the Hellcat was available; would have definitely gone with the Cat!!

[GunnyGene]

I have been very interested in the Hellcat ever since I first became aware of it.
Not much thicker than my XDS, and a significant increase in capacity. If I could step back to pre-purchase of my XDS and the Hellcat was available; would have definitely gone with the Cat!!

Likewise, but haven't been able to find one locally, and I don't buy guns without at least handling them, and preferably shooting a few rounds first. I'll spring the $5 or so for a test drive.

[JEBar]

As much as I hate to admit it, I think that would be the Hellcat. The trigger and sights on that little pistol make a big difference. The D/A pull on the 342 is smooth, but long and somewhat heavy, and the sights are not nearly as visible.

Howard

makes sense .... opinion appreciated

[markiver54]

I have been very interested in the Hellcat ever since I first became aware of it.
Not much thicker than my XDS, and a significant increase in capacity. If I could step back to pre-purchase of my XDS and the Hellcat was available; would have definitely gone with the Cat!!

Likewise, but haven't been able to find one locally, and I don't buy guns without at least handling them, and preferably shooting a few rounds first. I'll spring the $5 or so for a test drive.

Same here Gunny! Like to at least handle, if not shoot first. Have not had the chance yet to look very extensively, locally. Hope when time allows, I can find one.

[GunnyGene]

I have been very interested in the Hellcat ever since I first became aware of it.
Not much thicker than my XDS, and a significant increase in capacity. If I could step back to pre-purchase of my XDS and the Hellcat was available; would have definitely gone with the Cat!!

Likewise, but haven't been able to find one locally, and I don't buy guns without at least handling them, and preferably shooting a few rounds first. I'll spring the $5 or so for a test drive.

Same here Gunny! Like to at least handle, if not shoot first. Have not had the chance yet to look very extensively, locally. Hope when time allows, I can find one.

I missed one at the Academy in Tupelo by about 2 weeks. Counter guy said they were going to order a couple more next month. Priced at $503, which seems a little steep to me. Then there's 7% tax and NCIS fee of $25 which would put it at $563 out the door. I'll wait till our tax holiday rolls around in late Aug. before buying anyway.

[markiver54]

We have yet to get up to our summer cabin because of the extended tax deadline. ( wifes' an accountant ). However, when we do, the LGS up there is amazing, and I don't doubt that he will have one. Have bought most of my guns there and his prices can't be beat. He also stocks more Henrys than anywhere I've ever seen. ( Prices Creek General Store ) in Burnsville NC.
He's always well below MSRP, and sometimes even less for cash.